Seated Liberty Dollars Are Much Rarer Than Morgan and Peace Dollars

When it comes to collecting U.S. silver dollars, the Morgan and Peace dollars tend to dominate conversations. Their large mintages and historical significance have made them the centerpiece of many collections. However, seasoned numismatists know that the Seated Liberty dollar, which predates both series, is far rarer and holds a unique place in the history of American coinage.

The Origins of the Seated Liberty Dollar

Minted from 1840 to 1873, the Seated Liberty dollar was the first silver dollar produced by the U.S. Mint since the short-lived Gobrecht dollars of the late 1830s. The coin’s design, created by Christian Gobrecht, features Lady Liberty seated on a rock, holding a shield and a liberty cap on a pole. The reverse showcases an eagle with outstretched wings, a design rooted in tradition but with subtle changes introduced over the years.

The Seated Liberty dollar’s minting spanned a period of significant economic and political upheaval, including the California Gold Rush, the Civil War, and the eventual end of free silver coinage in 1873. These historical contexts contribute to the coin’s intrigue but also to its relatively low production numbers compared to later silver dollar series.

Why Are Seated Liberty Dollars So Rare?

Several factors contribute to the rarity of Seated Liberty dollars. First and foremost, the total mintage of the series was significantly lower than that of Morgan and Peace dollars. Over its 33-year run, fewer than 7 million Seated Liberty dollars were struck. By contrast, over 657 million Morgan dollars and 190 million Peace dollars were minted.

Additionally, the Seated Liberty dollar was not widely circulated. In the mid-19th century, paper money was a more convenient medium for large transactions, and the gold dollar had become a preferred option following the influx of gold from California. Many Seated Liberty dollars were shipped overseas for trade, where they either stayed in foreign markets or were melted down.

The Coinage Act of 1873, which effectively ended the production of Seated Liberty dollars, further cemented their scarcity. Known as the “Crime of 1873” by its detractors, the Act shifted U.S. monetary policy away from silver coinage, making these coins even harder to come by in subsequent years.

The Appeal to Collectors

For collectors, Seated Liberty dollars represent a unique challenge and opportunity. Many coins in the series are difficult to find in higher grades due to their age and the fact that they often saw heavy use when circulated. Notable key dates include the 1851 and 1852 Seated Liberty dollars, both of which had tiny mintages under 2,000 coins. The 1870-S Seated Liberty dollar is a legendary rarity, with only a handful of specimens known to exist.

The coin’s design is another draw for collectors. The artistry of the Seated Liberty series is widely regarded as a masterpiece of 19th-century American coinage. Its classical aesthetic stands in stark contrast to the bold designs of the Morgan and Peace dollars, making it a compelling addition to any collection.

Conclusion

While Morgan and Peace dollars enjoy widespread popularity, Seated Liberty dollars offer a glimpse into an earlier and less familiar era of American coinage. Their low mintages, historical significance, and stunning design make them a cornerstone for collectors seeking to own a truly rare piece of U.S. numismatic history.

Granny’s Garden School

FAQs