From the Dark Corner: An “Authenticated” Suspect Counterfeit 1799 Bust Dollar

The world of coin collecting is filled with intrigue, and few stories captivate collectors more than those of counterfeit coins slipping past even the most experienced eyes. One such tale involves a suspect counterfeit of the 1799 Draped Bust Dollar—an iconic piece of early American coinage. Despite being authenticated by a third-party grading service, the coin in question raised suspicions among experts, sparking a deeper dive into its origins and characteristics.

A Historical Treasure

The 1799 Draped Bust Dollar is a celebrated example of early U.S. coinage. Struck in 1799 during the presidency of John Adams, these coins feature a majestic design by engraver Robert Scot. The obverse showcases Liberty draped in flowing garments, her hair tied with a ribbon, while the reverse depicts a heraldic eagle with a shield and 13 stars representing the original colonies.

The Suspect Coin

The suspect 1799 Draped Bust Dollar found its way into a collector’s hands, having been authenticated and encapsulated by a respected third-party grading service. However, upon closer examination, certain irregularities began to emerge. These anomalies cast doubt on the coin’s authenticity, prompting a deeper investigation into its origins and possible fabrication techniques.

Key Red Flags

1. Unusual Surface Texture:
   Genuine Draped Bust Dollars are struck from silver planchets using high-pressure minting equipment of the era. As a result, authentic coins display a uniform surface texture with crisp details. The suspect coin, however, exhibited a subtle graininess indicative of casting—a common counterfeit method.
2. Weak Lettering and Stars:
   The lettering and stars on the suspect coin appeared slightly soft and uneven, lacking the sharpness expected of a genuine coin. These flaws are often the result of inferior dies or casting molds used by counterfeiters.
3. Weight Discrepancies:
   Authentic 1799 Bust Dollars weigh approximately 26.96 grams and are composed of 89.2% silver and 10.8% copper. The suspect coin’s weight and metallic composition differed slightly, a telltale sign of forgery. Counterfeiters frequently use alloys with a lower silver content to reduce production costs.
4. Die Characteristics:
   Close inspection revealed discrepancies in the die markers. Authentic 1799 Bust Dollars struck from the same die pairs share consistent characteristics, such as die cracks, clash marks, or wear patterns. The suspect coin displayed features inconsistent with known examples.

The Role of Authentication Services

The fact that this coin was authenticated by a reputable grading service highlights an important point: even the most experienced professionals are not infallible. Counterfeiting techniques have become increasingly sophisticated, making it difficult to identify fakes without advanced tools or exhaustive research.

In cases like this, collectors are reminded to approach high-value coins with caution, even when they come with professional certification. No grading service is immune to occasional errors, and the responsibility for due diligence ultimately rests with the buyer.

Lessons for Collectors

The case of the suspect 1799 Draped Bust Dollar underscores the importance of vigilance in the numismatic world. Collectors should always:

1. Educate Themselves: Study genuine examples of coins they wish to purchase, paying attention to details like weight, die markers, and design characteristics.
2. Buy From Reputable Sources: Established dealers and auction houses are less likely to handle counterfeit coins, reducing the risk of purchasing fakes.
3. Verify Suspicious Coins: If a coin raises doubts, seek a second opinion from a different grading service or an experienced numismatist.

Conclusion

The story of the suspect counterfeit 1799 Draped Bust Dollar serves as a cautionary tale for collectors. While authentication services play a critical role in ensuring the integrity of the numismatic market, no system is foolproof. By staying informed and exercising due diligence, collectors can protect themselves from falling victim to counterfeit coins. For every forged coin exposed, the numismatic community grows stronger in its quest to preserve the rich history of American coinage.

Granny’s Garden School

FAQs