Counterfeit Coin Detection – 1903-S Counterfeit Morgan Dollar

The Morgan Dollar, minted from 1878 to 1921, holds an iconic place in American numismatics. Among its many rarities, the 1903-S Morgan Dollar is particularly prized by collectors for its scarcity and value. However, this desirability has made it a prime target for counterfeiters. Detecting fake 1903-S Morgan Dollars requires a keen eye and some numismatic know-how.

The Historical Context of the 1903-S Morgan Dollar

The 1903-S Morgan Dollar was struck at the San Francisco Mint and is considered one of the rarer issues in the series. Due to relatively low mintage figures and limited survival rates, it commands high premiums in the collector market. Genuine examples in high grades often fetch thousands of dollars at auctions. This value makes them a lucrative target for counterfeiters, who exploit the scarcity to create convincing forgeries.

Common Types of Counterfeits

Counterfeit 1903-S Morgan Dollars can be broadly categorized into two types: die-struck counterfeits and altered coins. Die-struck counterfeits are created by replicating the design using counterfeit dies, often made using advanced technology. Altered coins, on the other hand, are made by modifying genuine Morgan Dollars to mimic the 1903-S.

One common method of alteration involves taking a more common Morgan Dollar and altering the mint mark to create the appearance of a 1903-S. For instance, counterfeiters may add an “S” mint mark to a Philadelphia-struck 1903 Morgan Dollar.

Detecting Counterfeit 1903-S Morgan Dollars

Identifying a counterfeit 1903-S Morgan Dollar requires careful examination of the coin’s physical characteristics, including the mint mark, strike quality, weight, and design details. Here are some tips:

1. Mint Mark Analysis:
   Genuine 1903-S Morgan Dollars feature a distinctive “S” mint mark, located on the reverse side beneath the wreath and above the “D” and “O” in “DOLLAR.” The mint mark should appear natural and exhibit the same wear patterns as the surrounding design. Counterfeit coins often display an added or altered mint mark that may seem irregular, uneven, or poorly aligned.
2. Weight and Composition:
   Authentic Morgan Dollars weigh approximately 26.73 grams and are composed of 90% silver and 10% copper. Use a precision scale to check the weight of the coin. Counterfeit coins often deviate from the standard weight due to incorrect metal composition.
3. Edge Reeding:
   Morgan Dollars have reeded edges with uniform, sharp grooves. Counterfeit coins might exhibit inconsistent or poorly executed edge reeding, which can be a clear red flag.
4. Design Details:
   The details of Liberty’s hair, the eagle’s feathers, and the wreath are finely executed on genuine coins. Counterfeit coins often have softer or less defined design elements due to inferior die craftsmanship. Use a magnifying glass or loupe to inspect these features closely.
5. Professional Authentication:
   For coins of significant value, such as the 1903-S Morgan Dollar, professional authentication by a reputable grading service (e.g., PCGS or NGC) is strongly recommended. These services provide a guarantee of authenticity and assign the coin a grade, further increasing its marketability.

Protecting Yourself from Counterfeits

To avoid falling victim to counterfeit 1903-S Morgan Dollars, follow these guidelines:

• Buy from Reputable Dealers: Purchase coins from established dealers with a proven track record of honesty and expertise.
• Seek Certified Coins: Invest in certified coins that have been authenticated and graded by professional services.
• Educate Yourself: Learn the key characteristics of genuine 1903-S Morgan Dollars to develop your detection skills.

Conclusion

The 1903-S Morgan Dollar’s rarity and high value make it an alluring target for counterfeiters. By carefully examining mint marks, weight, design details, and edge reeding, collectors can protect themselves from fakes. When in doubt, seek the expertise of professional numismatists or grading services to ensure authenticity. For serious collectors, the thrill of owning a genuine 1903-S Morgan Dollar lies not just in its value but in its rich historical legacy.

Granny’s Garden School

FAQs