Counterfeit Detection: Die-Struck Counterfeit 1916-D Mercury Dime

The 1916-D Mercury Dime is one of the most coveted key-date coins in American numismatics. With a low mintage of just 264,000, it is the rarest and most valuable Mercury Dime, making it a prime target for counterfeiters. While counterfeits exist in many forms, one of the most deceptive types is the die-struck counterfeit, a high-quality fake produced using fabricated dies. Detecting these counterfeits requires a keen eye and knowledge of the coin’s authentic characteristics.

What is a Die-Struck Counterfeit?

A die-struck counterfeit is created using fabricated dies to strike fake coins, mimicking the U.S. Mint’s official process. Unlike cast counterfeits, which often have porous surfaces and weak details, die-struck fakes can be highly deceptive, featuring sharp details and convincing luster. However, they still contain telltale errors that can be spotted by trained collectors and professionals.

Key Diagnostic Features of a Counterfeit 1916-D Mercury Dime

1. Mintmark Shape and Position

One of the biggest giveaways of a counterfeit 1916-D Mercury Dime is an incorrect D mintmark. Genuine 1916-D dimes have a small, well-defined D, placed in a very specific location on the reverse. Many counterfeits use:

• A larger, misshaped D that differs from the genuine mintmark.
• A misplaced or uneven D, often too high, too low, or tilted.
• An added D—some fakes start as a Philadelphia (no mintmark) 1916 dime with a counterfeit D mintmark added later.

2. Weak or Soft Details

Even well-made counterfeit dies often fail to replicate the crispness of the original design. Key areas to inspect include:

• Liberty’s Winged Cap: Authentic 1916-D dimes have sharp, well-defined feathers in Liberty’s cap. Fake versions often appear mushy or overly smooth.
• Date and Font: The numerals in “1916” should have a specific shape and spacing. Many counterfeits have slight variations in the size and alignment of the numbers.

3. Surface and Luster

• Die-struck counterfeits often exhibit unnatural luster or an odd surface texture, especially when struck with subpar dies.
• Some fakes have die polishing lines or unusual striations not found on genuine coins.
• If the coin has an artificially aged appearance, it may have been treated with chemicals to simulate wear.

4. Weight and Composition

A genuine 1916-D Mercury Dime should weigh 2.5 grams and have a composition of 90% silver and 10% copper. Counterfeits sometimes use incorrect metal compositions, leading to:

• Weight discrepancies (too light or too heavy).
• A non-silver appearance when tested with a magnet or electronic tester.

How to Verify Authenticity

1. Compare with Certified Examples: Use high-resolution images of authenticated 1916-D dimes from reputable sources like PCGS or NGC.
2. Use a Magnifier: A 10x loupe can help detect inconsistencies in the mintmark, surface, and details.
3. Seek Professional Authentication: If in doubt, send the coin to a professional grading service like PCGS, NGC, or ANACS for expert verification.

Conclusion

The 1916-D Mercury Dime is a numismatic treasure, but its rarity makes it a common target for counterfeiters. Die-struck counterfeits are among the most deceptive, but with careful examination of the mintmark, details, luster, and weight, collectors can confidently detect fakes. When in doubt, professional authentication is always the safest route to ensure your 1916-D Mercury Dime is the real deal.

Granny’s Garden School

FAQs