Counterfeit Coin Detection: Spark Erosion 1858 Flying Eagle Cent

The 1858 Flying Eagle cent is a popular and historic coin, representing one of the earliest small-sized cents in U.S. history. Because of its collectible value, counterfeit versions frequently surface in the market, including spark erosion counterfeits—a deceptive type of fake that can trick unsuspecting buyers. Understanding how to detect these counterfeits is essential for any numismatist.

What is a Spark Erosion Counterfeit?

Spark erosion counterfeiting is a process where a counterfeit die is created using electrical discharge machining (EDM). In this method, tiny electrical sparks gradually erode a real coin’s surface to form a mold, which is then used to produce fake coins. These counterfeits often have a grainy texture and lack the sharp details of genuine mint-struck coins.

Key Characteristics of a Spark Erosion 1858 Flying Eagle Cent Counterfeit

1. Surface Texture
   • Genuine Flying Eagle cents have a smooth, sharp, and well-defined surface.
   • Spark erosion counterfeits often have a rough, grainy, or pitted surface, especially in the fields (background areas).
2. Weak Lettering and Details
   • Authentic Flying Eagle cents display crisp, clear lettering and strong design details.
   • Counterfeits typically have weaker and more rounded edges on letters, numbers, and design elements due to the erosion process.
3. Unnatural Luster
   • Genuine coins show a natural cartwheel luster when rotated under a light.
   • Counterfeit coins often have a dull or inconsistent sheen, sometimes appearing too glossy or matte.
4. Raised Metal Bumps and Depressions
   • Spark erosion fakes often contain small raised bumps or pits that are not present on real coins.
   • These imperfections are caused by irregularities in the EDM process.
5. Edge and Rim Quality
   • The rims of a real 1858 Flying Eagle cent are well-formed with consistent thickness.
   • Spark erosion counterfeits often exhibit blurry or weakly defined rims, sometimes with an uneven edge.

Detecting Counterfeits with Advanced Methods

• Magnification: Using a 10x or higher magnifying glass can help spot the rough surfaces and weak details of a spark erosion counterfeit.
• Weight & Dimensions: Authentic 1858 Flying Eagle cents weigh approximately 4.67 grams and have a diameter of 19mm. Deviations may indicate a counterfeit.
• Professional Authentication: If uncertain, submitting the coin to a professional grading service like NGC, PCGS, or ANACS is the best way to verify authenticity.

Conclusion

The 1858 Flying Eagle cent is a highly sought-after coin, making it a target for counterfeiters who use spark erosion techniques. By learning to identify telltale signs such as grainy surfaces, weak details, and unnatural luster, collectors can protect themselves from purchasing fakes. When in doubt, seeking professional authentication is always the best course of action.

Granny’s Garden School

FAQs