Jeff Garrett: 1858-1915 Proof Type Coins

The era of 1858-1915 was a golden age for proof coinage in the United States. Numismatist Jeff Garrett, a leading expert in the field, has extensively studied proof type coins from this period, highlighting their historical significance, rarity, and appeal among collectors. These coins, struck with specially prepared dies and polished planchets, showcase some of the finest craftsmanship in U.S. Mint history.

The Beginning of Regular Proof Coinage (1858-1876)

Before 1858, proof coins were struck inconsistently, often in small quantities for dignitaries and collectors. However, in 1858, the U.S. Mint began producing proof coins on a more regular basis, offering them to collectors at a premium.

• Small Cents – The Flying Eagle cent (1856-1858) and the Indian Head cent (1859-1909) saw proof production, with early specimens being extremely rare.
• Silver Coinage – Dimes, quarters, half dollars, and dollars from the Seated Liberty series were struck in proof format, often in limited mintages.
• Gold Proofs – While less common, proof versions of the Liberty Head gold coins were also minted, though few have survived in pristine condition.

Collectors of this era sought proof coins for their brilliant surfaces, sharp strikes, and overall aesthetic appeal. These coins were not intended for circulation but rather for collectors and high-ranking officials.

The Expansion of Proof Coinage (1877-1907)

During this period, the demand for proof coins increased, and the U.S. Mint refined its production techniques. Proof sets became more widely available, often including cents, nickels, silver coins, and gold denominations.

Notable Proof Type Coins of the Era:

• Shield, Liberty, and Buffalo Nickels – These designs were minted in proof format with stunning detail. The 1880s Shield Nickels are particularly prized for their cameo contrasts.
• Barber Coinage (1892-1916) – Proof dimes, quarters, and half dollars of the Barber series feature deep mirrors and frosted devices, making them popular among collectors.
• Morgan and Peace Dollars – While most Morgan dollars were business strikes, some proof issues were created with remarkable quality.
• Gold Proofs – The Liberty Head and Indian Head gold coins, struck in proof form, are among the most coveted U.S. coins due to their beauty and rarity.

The Transition from Matte to Brilliant Proofs (1908-1915)

By the early 20th century, the Mint began experimenting with matte proof finishes, particularly on gold and larger silver coins. Unlike earlier brilliant proofs, matte proof coins had a soft, sandblasted texture, making them distinctive but less popular at the time.

Notable matte proof coins include:

• 1908-1915 Indian Head Gold Coins – The $2.50, $5, and $10 Indian Head gold pieces featured a matte finish that contrasted with traditional brilliant proofs.
• 1910-1915 Lincoln Cents – These matte proof cents are some of the rarest issues in U.S. numismatics today.
• Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle (1907-1915) – The $20 Saint-Gaudens gold piece was issued in both brilliant and matte proof finishes, with the latter being highly sought after.

Conclusion

Proof coin production changed drastically after 1915, as World War I shifted priorities away from numismatic products. It wasn’t until 1936 that the Mint resumed proof coinage, marking the end of this fascinating era.

Today, collectors prize proof coins from 1858-1915 for their historical significance, artistic excellence, and rarity. Jeff Garrett’s research has been instrumental in shedding light on these beautiful pieces, ensuring their legacy remains strong in the numismatic community.

Granny’s Garden School

FAQs